News
Email
Print
Groups call for defeat of proposed abortion rule
ADVERTISEMENT
Published: September 25, 2008
WASHINGTON
Several medical associations and 13 state attorneys general expressed their opposition yesterday to a proposed federal rule that they say would open the door for hospitals and physicians to deny access to contraception.
In late August, the Bush administration proposed stronger job protection for doctors and other health-care workers who refuse to participate in abortions because of religious or moral objections. Abortion foes called it a victory for the First Amendment, but abortion-rights supporters said they feared that the rule could stretch the definition of abortion to include birth control.
The public-comment period for the proposed rule ends today. As the deadline nears, opponents have organized a highly public call for the administration to rescind the rule. Although the regulation states that it would not limit access to health care, groups such as the American Psychiatric Association and the American Academy of Pediatrics disagreed.
They said that doctors and nurses are already not required to perform abortions or sterilizations. They can refuse to do so. But each health-care professional is ethically bound to inform patients about all of their treatment options. If health-care professionals cannot or will not provide a certain service, they are ethically obligated to refer patients in a timely manner to someone who can.
"Implementation of this regulation would effectively allow health-care providers' personal beliefs to override patients' right to full disclosure of accurate information and available health-care resources," the medical associations wrote.
Separately, 13 attorneys general said that the rule was too vague about what health-care procedures may be withheld.
"The proposed regulation completely obliterates the rights of patients to legal and medically necessary health-care services in favor of a single-minded focus on protecting a health-care provider's right to claim a personal moral or religious belief," the attorneys general said in a letter to the Department of Health and Human Services.
HHS spokeswoman Christina Pearson said she would not "speculate" on the department's course of action.
Email
Print
